Vermont Sues Man Who Sold Masks to Hospital at 'Unconscionable' Price | Off Message

Vermont Sues Man Who Sold Masks to Hospital at 'Unconscionable' Price


Masks sold to Central Vermont Medical Center - COURT FILINGS
  • Court filings
  • Masks sold to Central Vermont Medical Center
State prosecutors say a Williston businessman exploited a Vermont hospital by charging “unconscionable” prices for desperately needed surgical masks.

Shelley Palmer, owner of Big Brother Security Programs, sold thousands of basic surgical masks to Central Vermont Medical Center last month as the hospital was trying to respond to the coronavirus outbreak.

Such masks are worth around 10 cents each, but Palmer charged the nonprofit hospital $2.50 per mask, reaping an “exploitative gain” of at least $80,000, the Vermont Attorney General’s Office said.

The state sued Palmer and his company Tuesday for illegal price gouging, claiming the sales violated the Vermont Consumer Protection Act. The state is also seeking an emergency injunction to bar Palmer from selling more personal protective equipment, or PPE, in Vermont at exorbitant prices.

Masks and other PPE are essential to controlling the spread of the virus in hospitals and have been in short supply as the pandemic has swept through the country.

Palmer’s primary business involves nonemergency transportation for people with specialized needs. In an interview Tuesday, Palmer said he foresaw the coming pandemic, which he calls the “chicken curse,” and began ordering supplies through suppliers in China with the intent to resell them locally. He claimed he paid between 50 and 60 cents per mask but acknowledged his markup was still “steep.”

“There's no reason for me to spend all night long talking to the Chinese people if I'm not going to make any money,” he said.
Shelley Palmer assists a passenger into a taxi - FILE: MATTHEW THORSEN
  • File: MattHew Thorsen
  • Shelley Palmer assists a passenger into a taxi
Palmer said he struck up a conversation with CVMC employees during a hospital transport in March and offered to sell his masks. He claimed he negotiated the deal with director of patient support services David Cheney.

“I said, ‘What would you be willing to pay?’ He told me $2.50,” Palmer said.

In court filings, Cheney said he told Palmer the hospital usually paid 6 cents per mask but that it had “little choice” but to buy them at Palmer’s quoted price.

The state also accused Palmer of marketing the surgical masks as N95 respirators to a South Burlington urgent care clinic, a charge he denies.

Palmer told Seven Days his sales contributed to the public health response. Anticipating an unfavorable ruling in Vermont court, he has already moved his opportunistic side business to New York State, so he can continue selling elsewhere in the months ahead.

“I didn’t do it so I could earn a boatload of money,” he insisted. “That's a consequence.”

A court hearing is scheduled for April 22.

Read the state's motion for preliminary injunction below:

Related Stories

Speaking of...



Comments are closed.

From 2014-2020, Seven Days allowed readers to comment on all stories posted on our website. While we've appreciated the suggestions and insights, right now Seven Days is prioritizing our core mission — producing high-quality, responsible local journalism — over moderating online debates between readers.

To criticize, correct or praise our reporting, please send us a letter to the editor or send us a tip. We’ll check it out and report the results.

Online comments may return when we have better tech tools for managing them. Thanks for reading.