Vermont Publishing House Chelsea Green Is Peddling Coronavirus Misinformation | Business | Seven Days | Vermont's Independent Voice

News + Opinion » Business

Vermont Publishing House Chelsea Green Is Peddling Coronavirus Misinformation

By

Chelsea Green books - JOHN JAMES ©️ SEVEN DAYS
  • John James ©️ Seven Days
  • Chelsea Green books

In August, CNN dispatched a news crew to Florida to track down the world's most prolific disseminator of COVID-19 misinformation: Joseph Mercola, an osteopath with 4.3 million followers across 14 social media platforms who has been identified by the Center for Countering Digital Hate as the No. 1 spreader of pandemic falsehoods on the internet.

In more than 600 articles posted to his Facebook page since the pandemic began, Mercola has questioned the efficacy of masks and peddled thinly researched studies about the dangers of vaccines; in February, the U.S. Food & Drug Administration forced him to remove content from his website claiming that vitamins C and D can prevent and treat COVID-19 infections.

After a fruitless visit to the Mercola corporate headquarters in Cape Coral, the nerve center of his enterprise to push unproven supplement cures under the guise of natural health, the CNN crew buttonholed their man riding a bicycle near his gated mansion in Ormond Beach, sporting nothing but a pair of black swimming trunks, a baseball cap and a peanut butter tan.

"Do you feel responsible for people who didn't get vaccinated and possibly got sick and died because of what you've told them about the vaccines?" reporter Randi Kaye asked Mercola, who had just dismounted his bike at the entrance to the beach. Ignoring Kaye, he got back on and slowly pedaled away. Undeterred, Kaye fired more questions at him — "What do you say to families who've lost loved ones?" "Are you spreading misinformation?" "Why won't you speak to us?" — as his shirtless, shoeless silhouette receded silently into the distance.

The CNN segment neglected to mention that Mercola had recently coauthored a book called The Truth About COVID-19: Exposing the Great Reset, Lockdowns, Vaccine Passports, and the New Normal, which was released in April by a small, employee-owned outfit in White River Junction called Chelsea Green Publishing. Founded in the mid-1980s by married duo Margo and Ian Baldwin, the company has established a cult following as one of the preeminent publishers of books on homesteading, gardening and sustainable agriculture. Some of its longtime fans regard the Mercola book, now a best seller, as a betrayal of what they saw as Chelsea Green's progressive-minded mission.

"Shame on @chelseagreen, which I've always admired," journalist and Dartmouth College professor Jeff Sharlet tweeted last month. "This is murderous."

Stephen Kiernan, a novelist who lives in Charlotte, was horror-struck. "As far as I'm concerned, Chelsea Green's profit from this book is blood money," he said in an interview.

But these criticisms have had little audience with Margo Baldwin, who has been the publisher of Chelsea Green and president of its board of directors since 2002. In the few interviews she's granted since the book's release, Baldwin has not only argued for her right to print The Truth About COVID-19, she has endorsed its claims wholly.

"We have very knowledgeable editors who are experts in their subject areas, a rigorous acquisitions and manuscript review process, and access to many medical and health experts we call on when content exceeds our own knowledge," she recently told Washington Post book critic Ron Charles. When Charles asked whether she felt any responsibility for seeding baseless theories about the pandemic, Baldwin responded, "Our public responsibility is to the truth, as far as we can determine it. Creating a climate of fear and misinformation is what mainstream media seems to excel at, not independent publishers like Chelsea Green."

Chelsea Green has always dabbled in fringier subjects, but in recent years, its antiauthoritarian ethos has taken the form of books, such as Mercola's, that employ debunked science and alarmist rhetoric to challenge or outright reject the medical and scientific establishment. In a global health crisis that has raised the stakes of proliferating such misinformation, Chelsea Green has found itself in an ethically precarious position.

Kevin Ellis, a political strategist and one of Chelsea Green's four board members, said he believes that publishers "have a right to be wrong"; the cost of their mistakes, in his view, is beside the point.

"Your next question is, 'Well, yeah, but some people are going to die,'" he said. "And I'm going to say, 'Yeah, you're right, and we accept that.' We accept highway deaths; we accept diabetes; we accept spending billions of dollars to repair the damage that we allow the junk food industry to do. People are too stupid to make judgments about their own health. I think that's a problem with democracy, not some tiny little publisher in White River Junction."




Selling Like Hot Takes

Dr. Joseph Mercola - COURTESY OF MERCOLA.COM

If you googled how to, say, build a house from bales of straw, or grow salad greens in your closet, or manage a worm farm, or rewild Britain's waterways with beavers, you might stumble upon the website of Chelsea Green, an unlikely success story in the failure-riddled ecosystem of upstart publishers. The Baldwins moved from New York City to the Upper Valley in the early '80s, lured by the same visions of verdure and self-sufficiency that had seduced generations of back-to-the-landers before them.

Ian had worked in publishing in New York, and, in 1984, the couple scrounged $115,000 to start an independent press out of a white clapboard farmhouse on the Chelsea town green, for which they named the company. The Baldwins' early projects reflected their own roving interests: an illustrated guide to the cemeteries of Paris, a fable about a shepherd who spends his life planting trees in Provence, a compendium of the art and writings of Norwegian painter Edvard Munch. Some years were lean; at one point, Ian said in a 1999 New York Times story on Chelsea Green, he nearly sold the business. 

But he didn't, and in the late '80s and early '90s, before the organic food and climate movements had become part of the popular consciousness, the Baldwins published three books that demonstrated their knack for anticipating the zeitgeist and defined their niche — Loving and Leaving the Good Life, a memoir by back-to-the-lander Helen Nearing; The New Organic Grower, a sort of bible for young farmers; and Limits to Growth, which pioneered the idea that the human population might someday exceed Earth's carrying capacity.

Over the next few decades, Chelsea Green's sales grew, from $2 million in 1999 to $5 million in 2015. The company is now fully owned by its 29 employees, with an office in London and a catalog of more than 400 titles, some of which have remained in print for more than three decades, on topics ranging from fermentation to the cultural history of okra.

But the Baldwins' penchant for heterodox thinking has also manifested itself in books advocating vaccine skepticism, written by authors of dubious credentials. In 2018, Chelsea Green published two books linking autism and chronic disease to childhood vaccinations: How to End the Autism Epidemic by J.B. Handley, a businessman with no medical training, and Vaccines, Autoimmunity, and the Changing Nature of Childhood Illness by Thomas Cowan, a California doctor whose license to practice was suspended earlier this year as a result of his YouTube videos promoting the conspiracy theory that the 5G network caused the COVID-19 pandemic. 

Vaccine skepticism has long existed in some of the wellness enclaves in which Chelsea Green books tend to succeed, and the Handley and Cowan books both sold exceptionally well. This April, in the midst of a pandemic that has galvanized a new wave of anti-vaccine activism, Chelsea Green released Mercola's The Truth About COVID-19, which has become one of its best-selling titles yet.

The book, coauthored with Ronnie Cummins, cofounder of the nonprofit Organic Consumers Association, has already sold more than a quarter million copies; as of September 15, it was the 25th most popular title on Amazon and a No. 1 best seller in a handful of categories, including Diseases & Physical Ailments, Sociological Study of Medicine, and Censorship & Politics.

An Amazon search for the term "COVID-19" yields The Truth About COVID-19 as the top result, which prompted U.S. Rep. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) and Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) to send a letter earlier this month to the online retail behemoth's top executives, imploring them to modify the site's algorithms to limit the visibility of products that promote misinformation and conspiracy theories. (The Amazon page for The Truth About COVID-19 features a discreet blue banner advising customers to visit the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's website for the latest information on vaccines.) 

The book posits, among other things, that COVID-19 was engineered as a bioweapon, then leaked — deliberately, Mercola invites us to believe — from a poorly managed laboratory in Wuhan, China, then exploited by a cabal of global elites to strip us of our inalienable rights and render us all frightened and impotent. Based on what appears to be a cursory review of all the journalism outlets that have ever received grants from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Mercola assumes the Trump-like posture that mainstream media outlets — BBC, NBC, ProPublica, the Atlantic and the Center for Investigative Reporting, to name a few — have been bought by Gates to advance falsehoods about the pandemic and, therefore, the Big Tech agenda.

"Very little makes sense anymore," Mercola writes, "unless you look at it from the perspective we've tried to present to you here, namely that this pandemic has been used as a convenient cover story (and may even have been pre-planned) to facilitate and hide the transfer of wealth to unelected technocrats who control the pandemic narrative, while simultaneously justifying the erosion of your personal freedoms and civil liberties." 

Mercola has devoted a significant portion of his career to marketing vaccine hesitancy, and he allots a chapter of his book to selling the claim that COVID-19 vaccines are far more deadly than the virus itself. He refers to the virus, cleverly, as a "biological trigger" that worsens preexisting conditions, such as obesity and chronic illnesses, which are themselves the result of the cheap processed foods with which Big Ag has contrived to sicken Americans.

"People are dying with COVID-19," he writes, "as opposed to dying from it." Among the prevention and cure methods he touts are ivermectin, food-grade hydrogen peroxide inhaled through a nebulizer, and hydroxychloroquine, none of which has been approved by the FDA to treat COVID-19. Mercola also recommends a regimen of vitamin supplements, which he happens to sell on his website.

Through a spokesperson, Mercola told Seven Days he intends to donate the proceeds from the book to the National Vaccine Information Center, the country's leading anti-vaccine advocacy group. In 2019, the Washington Post reported that Mercola had already given $2.9 million to the organization over the past decade, supplying nearly 40 percent of its total funding.

"Mercola is an extremely sophisticated con man," said Bernie Garrett, a professor of nursing at the University of British Columbia in Vancouver. Chelsea Green holds the U.S. rights to Garrett's recent book, The New Alchemists: The Rise of Deceptive Healthcare, which contains a section on Mercola's supplement empire. "He's great at cherry-picking data from basic, low-quality lab experiments and computer studies, and he ignores mountains of randomized trials and high-quality evidence that disprove his points," Garrett said. "It's totally irresponsible of Chelsea Green to publish his book at this time, and it's pretty depressing to me that my book is up on their website along with his."

Margo Baldwin refused to speak with Seven Days in person or over the phone, and she agreed only to answer questions by email if she deemed them "worth responding to." In the end, she replied directly to just a few points out of more than a dozen questions — among them, that her responses to Ron Charles, the Washington Post book critic, sounded like a defense of the factual integrity of The Truth About COVID-19.

"Of course I am defending the factual integrity of the book!" Margo wrote back. "It is one of the most important books we have ever published. Given the incredible misinformation promulgated by the public health bureaucracy and the mainstream media, ordinary people need access to the truth about what is really going on.

"You may not agree with that," she continued, "but that does not mean you have truth on your side." 




'What We're All About Here'

Margo Baldwin in 2014 - COURTESY OF VALLEY NEWS/SARAH PRIESTAP
  • Courtesy Of Valley News/Sarah Priestap
  • Margo Baldwin in 2014

Chelsea Green has long occupied a strange place at the crossroads of the antiestablishment left and the libertarian right. Stephen Morris, who ran the publishing operations from 1995 to 2002, recalls a book convention at the Javits Center in New York City in the early 2000s, during which someone approached the Chelsea Green booth, raving about their titles.

"He was saying how much he loved us, that he had every book we'd ever published, that he'd loved this book and that book and this other book," said Morris. "The more we talked, the more it became apparent that this guy was a real survivalist, and his Chelsea Green bookshelf was in his bunker." 

Meanwhile, an editor who had worked on many of those books looked on in dismay. "He said, 'Get this guy out of the booth! He doesn't represent what we're all about here!'" said Morris. "Yet they were united by the same assumptions. The guy believed in organic food. He believed that we were in danger of losing our pollinators. He bought into all the stuff that we were publishing, but from a very different direction."

In fact, according to several former employees, Chelsea Green has made a calculated effort to separate its audiences — the one that shows up for books on beekeeping and no-till farming, and the one that comes for books by Mercola, Cowan and Handley. That these groups certainly overlap in real life is immaterial; the point, as one former employee explained, is to avoid upsetting the fans of beekeeping and no-till farming who would find Chelsea Green's anti-vaccine treatises, internally known as "the health titles," too outré for their tastes. 

"The digital director would never put that stuff out on Facebook," said the ex-employee, who requested anonymity for fear of hurting her future job prospects. Instead, authors such as Mercola, who has more than 317,000 Twitter followers, deploy their own social media machinery to promote their books. "I think Margo is very aware that the health stuff will sell in the channels it needs to sell in without disrupting the other audience," the ex-employee said.

This principle apparently does not apply to Margo herself, who tweets freely about the "fascism" of mask and vaccine mandates, the media's attempts to silence proponents of ivermectin, and the "censorship" of Mercola. When Mercola tweeted a recent NPR story about Schiff and Warren's appeal to Amazon, noting, in his coyly provocative fashion, that NPR had received $17 million in funding from the Gates Foundation and did not reach out to him for comment, Margo shared his tweet. "Of course not!" she wrote. (The official Chelsea Green Twitter account has not retweeted any of Margo's musings on the pandemic.)

There is nothing particularly novel, of course, about a business curating its online presence. But another former Chelsea Green employee, who ran the company's Instagram account during his tenure, said that the prospect of a massive backlash, and his own moral instinct, was enough to dissuade him from promoting the anti-vaccine books.

"First of all, I didn't want to have anything to do with them," he said. "Second, I did not want to be on the receiving end of justifiably angry and freaked out people unfollowing us in droves, because I knew that that would happen."

Like most of the former Chelsea Green employees Seven Days interviewed, this ex-employee also requested anonymity; Vermont's literary community is small, he said, and Margo wields considerable influence in it.

When he started his job at Chelsea Green, he said, he was eager to work on well-researched books about sustainable food and progressive politics. But as time went on, he became increasingly perplexed by some of Chelsea Green's titles in science, medicine and sociology. "I started to wonder, What is the connection between all of this stuff? Do all the books we're doing make sense for our mission? I couldn't figure it out," he said.

In spite of Chelsea Green's employee-ownership model, former staff members spoke of a very top-down workplace, where people rarely feel empowered to disagree with Margo; the Chelsea Green board of directors, over which Margo presides, has no employee representation. (In response to Seven Days' question about what, precisely, the employee-ownership model entails, Margo wrote: "What business is that of yours and why is it relevant?")

The common denominator among all of Chelsea Green's editorial acquisitions, said the ex-employee, was Margo. In recent years, he said, she'd become especially fond of books that take on the medical establishment, and she would tear down people who challenged her, often in front of their colleagues.

"We'd have meetings where these books would come up for discussion, but it just felt like a formality," he said. "If she wanted to publish a book, it was a foregone conclusion." A former Chelsea Green intern, who said she rejected a full-time job offer because she didn't want to work under Margo, recalled that during the editorial meeting to discuss the Cowan book, Vaccines, Autoimmunity, and the Changing Nature of Childhood Illness, one editor became so upset that he had to leave the room. 

The ex-employee who ran the Instagram account stayed at Chelsea Green for seven years, in part because he strongly believed in the work that Chelsea Green had done in other fields, and also because he didn't think that he was experienced enough to get a publishing job in a place like New York City — not to mention that outside of Chelsea Green, book publishing jobs are practically nonexistent in Vermont. 

"I was able to work with amazing authors on books that I was really proud of, and that I will always be proud of," said the ex-employee. "That made it easier for me to make excuses, or to pretend that certain books weren't big warning signs that I definitely could have quit over based on my moral code." 

His resolve finally broke, he said, when he learned that Chelsea Green would publish the 15th-anniversary edition of Not in His Image by John Lamb Lash, whose writings on gnosticism and pagan spirituality have been embraced by white supremacist and anti-vaccination groups. (An excerpt from the flap copy of the 15th-anniversary book, which was released last week, reads: "Lash ... shows how the Gnostics clearly foresaw the current program of salvation by syringe, and places the Sophianic vision of life centrally in the battle to expose and oppose the evil agenda of transhumanism, making this well-timed update more relevant than ever.") 

"It made me feel naïve and stupid to be building my career at a place where I didn't pick up on these things, on top of feeling complicit in them," he said. He quit earlier this year, before the Mercola deal had been finalized. The Truth About COVID-19 came as no surprise, he said: "Anything on COVID that was going to stick it to Big Pharma or national public health measures felt in line with the ethos of our other health books."

In fact, the Mercola book wasn't the first COVID-19-related title Chelsea Green published; in October 2020, the company acquired the English translation of a German book called Corona, False Alarm?, which cast doubt on lockdowns and other government interventions. "What struck me about it was that it almost felt ready-made, like it was just seizing upon this moment," said the ex-employee. "And at the same time, its critique of Big Pharma and mainstream medicine was that they were moving too fast."




The Bottom Line

Dan Wing - COURTESY OF DINA DUBOIS
  • Courtesy Of Dina Dubois
  • Dan Wing

As publisher, Margo is responsible for the business side of Chelsea Green, and the profitability of these controversial books, said another former employee, isn't lost on her. "I think the times I saw her happiest were when she was talking about books that were selling really well," she observed.

Jim Schley, a freelance contributor to Seven Days who was editor in chief of Chelsea Green from the early '90s until 2002, agreed with that assessment.

"I think that when it comes down to it, she is motivated by money," said Schley, who was laid off along with roughly half a dozen other employees when Margo reorganized the company and installed herself as publisher. "Margo would never admit that, and I'm sure she would say that she has very high-minded principles. But I do see a history of relishing controversy, which she can use to justify making buckets of money. She gets an adrenaline rush out of conflict and a kind of pleasure out of believing that other people are stupid." ("Ha, ha, I'm a bad boss! Gee, what a story!" Margo wrote in an email to Seven Days. "Do you really think anyone cares?")

But Margo also seems to genuinely subscribe to some of the more iconoclastic ideas in Chelsea Green's literature, and former employees said she makes no secret of her convictions. Throughout the pandemic, according to another recent ex-employee, Margo has eschewed masks in the office and shamed other staffers for wearing them. Nobody stood up to her," she said, "because they were afraid of losing their jobs."

Within her first few weeks at Chelsea Green, said the same former employee, Margo tried to convince her that 9/11 was an inside job; there was an unwritten rule in the office never to tell Margo about dentist appointments, several people noted, so as not to find oneself on the receiving end of a lecture about how modern dentistry leads to mercury poisoning. 

And yet, those kinds of theories occasionally contain some speck of truth, which can make them irresistible to people who already view powerful institutions as self-serving and corrupt. Garrett, the University of British Columbia nursing professor, pointed to the decades of manipulation and deceit by drug-manufacturing giants such as Purdue Pharma, which downplayed the addictiveness of its painkillers and fueled an opioid epidemic that has claimed at least half a million lives.

"Every once in a while, something does get peeled back — look at the conservatives packing the courts, gerrymandering, the EB-5 scandal," said Dan Wing, a retired doctor and author of the 1999 Chelsea Green book on artisanal bread and masonry ovens, The Bread Builders, which is still in print. "Is American agriculture just an economic phenomenon, or is it a conspiracy? It's easy to imagine how someone might start with organic apple farming and go down the rabbit hole." 

Wing, who lives in Corinth and is immunocompromised, was horrified by The Truth About COVID-19. "I was fundamentally proud of having had my book published by Chelsea Green," he said. "Now, I feel creepy about the association."

Wing collects about $1,000 a year in royalties from his book, and he said he doesn't know whether it would even be possible for him to change publishers.

"If I took that $1,000 and gave it to the Union of Concerned Scientists instead, that would probably make me feel better," said Wing. "But I don't think anyone has fully solved this problem. If your grandfather purchased a share of an oil well, and you were receiving income from that oil well, and you sold your share because you don't like fossil fuels, somebody else is still pumping oil. And what about Amazon? Do you have a Prime account because you want to watch a movie, even though you're supporting a company that has bad labor practices? You can slice and dice it forever, until you wind up standing naked and alone."

Margo, for her part, seems to feel far from alone. In her defense of The Truth About COVID-19, she wrote in an email: "There are over 2,500 5-star reviews of the book on Amazon. Maybe you should spend some time reading them."

The original print version of this article was headlined "Best-Selling Bunk"