The Great American Cookbook | Food News | Seven Days | Vermont's Independent Voice

Food + Drink » Food News

The Great American Cookbook

by

comment

I spent this morning with my "little" sister, who is living at my mom's house while she waits for her PhD program to begin in the fall. We visited the Burlington Farmers' Market and had lunch with a friend at a new restaurant (teaser warning) that I'll be writing about for next week's paper.

As I drove down my mom's street to drop my sister off, I noticed a small yard sale. From the (slowly) moving car, I spied a book with a pie on the front cover. So of course, I had to pay a visit.

The book in question was a nice-looking 2005 hardcover called The Great American Cookbook. At $5 it seemed like a good value, so I snapped it up. Now, I already had 8 cookbooks with "America" or "USA" in the titles, but there's something different about this one...it's the only one of the bunch that was actually printed in another country -- England. Well, technically it was printed in Malaysia, but the publisher is in Britain.

To me, this changes the whole nature of examining the book. Usually I comb through a new cookbook searching out exciting-sounding recipes that I'll probably never make. I take for granted that an American author's take on American cuisine is accurate. Or that the recipes in my newest Thai cookbook are representative of Thai cuisine. But this time, I looked through wondering, "what do THEY think American cooking is all about?" What I found is a combination of recipes that made me say "yep, right on...those are quintessential American foods" and others just made me say, "huh?" Here a some samples from each category:

Yep, right on: cioppino (invented in San Fran), oysters Rockefeller, po' boys, hamburgers (did you know that sandwich buns are called "baps" in England? Weird.), blueberry pancakes, apple pie, southern fried chicken...you get the idea.

Huh?: chilled avocado and cilantro soup (sounds great, but I've never had it, nor seen it on a restaurant menu anywhere), three-bean burgers with green mayo, seafood pizza, sweet-and-sour glazed onions,  broiled bell pepper relish, peach and pecan empanadas...all yummy sounding, but don't seem to define American cuisine.

I envision someone in another country nodding her head and thinking, "huh, so that's what they eat over there." And it makes me more wary about jumping to conclusions when I view American-produced cookbooks about other nations!

 

Add a comment

Seven Days moderates comments in order to ensure a civil environment. Please treat the comments section as you would a town meeting, dinner party or classroom discussion. In other words, keep commenting classy! Read our guidelines...

Note: Comments are limited to 300 words.