The 251 Club Encourages Vermonters to Explore Roads Less Traveled | Staytripper | Seven Days | Vermont's Independent Voice

Local Guides » Staytripper

The 251 Club Encourages Vermonters to Explore Roads Less Traveled


Published February 23, 2021 at 10:00 a.m.
Updated March 16, 2021 at 3:31 p.m.

View of McCullough Turnpike on Route 17 - COURTESY OF MATT AND ANN PARSONS
  • Courtesy Of Matt And Ann Parsons
  • View of McCullough Turnpike on Route 17

Montpelier resident Brenda Greika has settled into a weekend routine during the pandemic. She packs up her car with ample food and drinks, pops a Starline Rhythm Boys or Patti Casey CD into her player, and drives to a Vermont town she's never been to before.

To celebrate Halloween, Greika visited Evergreen Cemetery in New Haven to see a gravestone with a window built into it. It belongs to 19th-century doctor Timothy Clark Smith, who feared being buried alive and was reportedly entombed with a hammer. In January, Greika ended up at the NorthWoods Stewardship Center in East Charleston, where she communed with a barred owl.

Brenda Greika with a barred owl in East Charleston - COURTESY OF BRENDA GREIKA
  • Courtesy Of Brenda Greika
  • Brenda Greika with a barred owl in East Charleston

Sometimes, she'll just turn down a dirt road to see where it leads. "You're going to meet cows, moose, deer," she said. "Eventually, you'll pop out in some of the most amazing places you've seen in your life."

Greika is a member of the 251 Club of Vermont, an organization composed of 4,200 people who share the same goal: visiting all 251 towns and cities in the state. Greika joined the club in the late 1980s and now sits on its board of directors. She described it as "one of my saving graces" during the pandemic.

Eve Ermer and Scott Russell at Lewis Pond Overlook - COURTESY OF EVE ERMER AND SCOTT RUSSELL
  • Courtesy Of Eve Ermer And Scott Russell
  • Eve Ermer and Scott Russell at Lewis Pond Overlook

The club was founded more than 65 years ago by Vermont Life contributor Dr. Arthur Wallace Peach. In 1954, inspired by readers' queries about how they could know "the real Vermont," Peach proposed an informal group encouraging Vermonters and those who loved the state "to discover the secret and lovely places that main roads do not reveal."

For decades, the club included a large number of older, retired members, said executive director Stephanie Young. The Burlington resident took the wheel in January 2020 with a goal of making the organization more accessible to a broader audience.

Arlington welcome sign - COURTESY OF PAT AND JOHN WILLIAMS
  • Courtesy Of Pat And John Williams
  • Arlington welcome sign

Before Young — a law professor who teaches online for Purdue University Global — took charge, joining the club required filling out a paper form and mailing in a check. She implemented an online payment system and launched Facebook and Twitter accounts to establish a social media presence. The club's quarterly newsletter is now delivered to members digitally, as well as in its original paper form.

Pat and John Williams upon completing all 251 towns and two gores - COURTESY OF PAT AND JOHN WILLIAMS
  • Courtesy Of Pat And John Williams
  • Pat and John Williams upon completing all 251 towns and two gores

In the past year, said Young, more families and young people have joined. Take Burlington High School senior Parker Ballard, who signed up last spring to combat the boredom of remote learning. By fall, he'd checked the last town off his list.

Boardman Hill Road in West Rutland - COURTESY OF KRISTEN JARVI
  • Courtesy Of Kristen Jarvi
  • Boardman Hill Road in West Rutland

The club, which counts Gov. Phil Scott and U.S. Rep. Peter Welch (D-Vt.) among its rank and file, has been around long enough that it now has second-generation members. Burlington resident Thom Fleury, a principal at Leicester Central School, learned about the organization from his parents, early members who completed the mission as retirees.

It took Fleury 11 years — from 1987 to 1998 — to reach 251. In each town he visited, Fleury sent himself a postcard with a message detailing his visit. He keeps those postcards, alphabetized by town, in a library card catalog at his home and periodically flips through them.

One of his favorite 251 Club activities was visiting rustic roadside eateries. He recalled a particularly good breakfast at the Busy Bee Diner in Glover. His least favorite trip? The one in which he picked up a speeding ticket.

Kathy and Charles Giurtino in Montpelier - COURTESY OF KATHY AND CHARLES GIURTINO
  • Courtesy of Kathy and Charles Giurtino
  • Kathy and Charles Giurtino in Montpelier

At a post office in Beecher Falls, a village near the Canadian border with a population of about 200, an affable postmistress greeted Fleury in French. Since she didn't recognize him as one of the townspeople, he explained, she must have assumed he was a tourist from north of the border.

Young said club members — roughly 88 percent of whom live in Vermont — have displayed ample creativity in how they carry out their visits. One walked through every town, racking up a total of 1,666 miles over 606 hours. Another hit a golf ball in each of the places he visited.

And then there are newlyweds Loretta Cruz and Aaron Agnew of South Royalton, who joined the club last summer after their planned honeymoon to Maine's Acadia National Park fell through due to COVID-19. Instead, they spent time exploring Bennington and Rutland counties, checking towns off their list.

Young isn't just the leader of the 251 Club; she's also an active member. In the eight years her family has lived in Vermont, they've visited 122 towns. Recently, she said, they took a weekend trip to the southern part of the state, hitting another eight towns.

  • Courtesy Of Stephanie Young
  • Lake Dunmore

In Rockingham, they visited the Vermont Country Store and bought truffles and old-timey Charles Chips to snack on during their drive. In Grafton, they got a grilled cheese at the town's general store, MKT: Grafton, that was so delicious they're still talking about it. And in Stratton, they went snow tubing, cross-country skiing and snowshoeing. Young's two school-age sons especially liked Mountain Sweets, the candy store in the center of town.

"The club is so appealing because it's a challenge, and it gets you out there to discover the parts of Vermont you might not have discovered," she said.

Painted silos in Cambridge - COURTESY OF MATT AND ANN PARSONS
  • Courtesy Of Matt And Ann Parsons
  • Painted silos in Cambridge

Some destinations are notorious among club members, Young noted. Lewis, population zero, is so difficult to find that members often leave it until the end. And Glastenbury is part of the "Bennington Triangle," said Greika — an area known for its spooky and strange happenings.

Greika is saving that town for last; if aliens abduct her, she said with a laugh, she'll at least have visited all 251 towns.

Though she was born in Connecticut, Greika said Vermont has her heart. "Every town has their own little specialty — either food, arts or musicians," she said. "To me, if you love Vermont, she'll love you back. Just go out there and feel the love."

Correction February 28, 2021: An earlier version of this story misidentified Beecher Falls' settlement type. It is a village in the town of Canaan.

Learn more about the 251 Club of Vermont at Membership costs $22 for one year or $58 for five years.

The original print version of this article was headlined "Roads Less Traveled | The 251 Club encourages Vermonters to explore the state"

Vermont Vacation logoFind more information on Vermont day trips and adventures from the Vermont Department of Tourism and Marketing at