Winner
Buttered Noodles
Winner
Woodbury Mountain Toys
Those who believe toy shopping should be a tactile experience that involves more than typing on a keyboard and clicking a mouse should thank Buttered Noodles owner Alan Levi for bucking trends. He turned mostly e-commerce company KidSurplus into a brick-and-mortar Williston destination with some 3000 items, from sunscreen to rain boots. Activities such as story time and “Music With Mr. Chris” increase the “stickiness” or “hang-time” factor for customers, who linger for many minutes and come in multiple times per week.
As for that name? It was the Levi kids’ (now 28 and 29) favorite food. Though some customers were initially shocked to discover a kids’ store instead of a pasta eatery at lunchtime, Buttered Noodles generally whets shopping appetites instead.
SEVEN DAYS: Do you really serve buttered noodles?
ALAN LEVI: We serve buttered noodles on character days, such as when Froggy or Curious George comes to the store. Then four or five of us whip up 50 to 100 pounds of buttered noodles, with real butter, and we serve it all day, from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.
—Sarah Tuff
Turner Toys
| Aug 2, 2023
Turner Toys
| Aug 3, 2022
Jamie Two Coats' Toy Shop
| Jul 31, 2019
Jamie Two Coats' Toy Shop
| Aug 1, 2018
Jamie Two Coats' Toy Shop
| Aug 2, 2017
Once Upon a Time Toys
| Aug 3, 2016
Woodbury Mountain Toys
| Aug 5, 2015
Buttered Noodles
| Jul 30, 2014
Woodbury Mountain Toys
| Aug 7, 2012
Woodbury Mountain Toys
| Aug 3, 2011