Winner:
Sneakers Bistro & Café
Runner-Up:
Penny Cluse Café
Winner:
Main Street Grill & Bar
Runner-Up:
Mist Grill
Penny Cluse Café (Burlington) & Main Street Grill & Bar (Montpelier)
| Aug 9, 2006
Penny Cluse Café (Burlington) & Main Street Grill & Bar (Montpelier)
| Jul 28, 2004
Sneakers Bistro & Café (Winooski) & The Mist Grill (Waterbury)
| Jul 22, 2003