Scott's Victory Lap: Gov Wins Third Term, Gray Elected LG, Speaker Johnson Falls Short | Off Message

Scott's Victory Lap: Gov Wins Third Term, Gray Elected LG, Speaker Johnson Falls Short


Gov. Phil Scott declares victory Tuesday in a video shot in his motorcycle garage. - SCREENSHOT ©️ SEVEN DAYS
  • Screenshot ©️ Seven Days
  • Gov. Phil Scott declares victory Tuesday in a video shot in his motorcycle garage.
Updated at 4:28 a.m.

Republican Gov. Phil Scott waltzed to a third term on Tuesday, while Democratic newcomer Molly Gray was elected Vermont’s fourth female lieutenant governor.

And in the upset of the evening, House Speaker Mitzi Johnson (D-South Hero) appeared headed for defeat. Unofficial results showed Rep. Leland Morgan (R-Milton) and his nephew, fellow Milton Republican Michael Morgan, ahead in the two-seat House district — with Johnson trailing 18 votes behind the latter. Given the narrow margin, Johnson declined to concede on Tuesday night and said she would seek a recount.

“It’s not uncommon for Vermont House elections to be extremely close,” she said in a written statement. “Over the years, we’ve seen tight races and recounts in this district. I want to ensure every vote is counted and that we have clarity on the outcome of this election.”
House Speaker Mitzi Johnson (D-South Hero) - FILE: JEB WALLACE-BRODEUR
  • File: Jeb Wallace-Brodeur
  • House Speaker Mitzi Johnson (D-South Hero)
The 2020 election saw the highest voter turnout in state history. With 97 percent of precincts reporting early Wednesday morning, more than 353,000 ballots had been counted, according to the Secretary of State’s Office. Vermont’s previous record, set in 2008, was 326,822.

Though the outcome of the presidential election remained unclear early Wednesday, the preference of Vermonters was readily apparent. Preliminary results showed Democratic former vice president Joe Biden leading Republican President Donald Trump 66 to 30 percent. That’s a wider margin than in 2016, when Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton led Trump 56 to 30 percent, with 6 percent writing in Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.).

Scott, 62, appeared to have won the biggest victory of his three runs for governor. As of Wednesday morning, he was leading his Progressive/Democratic challenger, Lt. Gov. David Zuckerman, 67 to 27 percent — a margin of 40 percentage points.
In 2016 and 2018, Scott vanquished Democratic rivals by nine and 15 points, respectively.

Gray, meanwhile, claimed nearly 50 percent of the vote in her first electoral outing, while her Republican opponent, Scott Milne, picked up 42 percent.

Gov. Scott voting Tuesday in Berlin - PAUL HEINTZ ©️ SEVEN DAYS
  • Paul Heintz ©️ Seven Days
  • Gov. Scott voting Tuesday in Berlin
Scott declared victory Tuesday night in video he recorded in his Berlin motorcycle garage. “Today, Vermonters have spoken, and I’m humbled to earn your support once again,” he said.

The two-term governor and former construction executive acknowledged that his victory had come during “some of the greatest challenges of our lifetime.” He pointed to the coronavirus pandemic, which has ravaged the nation and recently resurged in Vermont, as well as the country’s partisan divide.

“Our nation is hurting — not just from COVID-19 but because of another virus that has infected the hearts and minds of too many Americans: that of hate, fear and division,” Scott said. “We must confront this with the same force and energy we’re putting toward the coronavirus.”

Scott, who barely campaigned for a third term, staked his reelection race on the state’s response to the pandemic — as well as his own distinctive brand of moderate Republican politics. After voting in the Berlin town offices Tuesday afternoon, he disclosed that he had cast a ballot for Biden over Trump, becoming the only incumbent Republican governor to do so.

“I put country over party,” Scott explained.
Lt. Gov. David Zuckerman at his election night party in Burlington - JAMES BUCK
  • James Buck
  • Lt. Gov. David Zuckerman at his election night party in Burlington
In his own remarks to an online gathering hosted by the Vermont Democratic Party, Zuckerman said he had called to congratulate Scott moments earlier. The organic farmer from Hinesburg said he had told the governor he was “ready to stand by him for our democracy, for the decency that we represent in Vermont.”

The race for lieutenant governor pitted two lesser-known figures against one another in the most competitive state contest of the year. Gray, a 36-year-old assistant attorney general from Burlington, had promised to fight for greater access to broadband, affordable childcare and paid family leave. Milne, a 61-year-old travel executive from Pomfret, said he would work to help small businesses recover from the effects of COVID-19. 
Gray had never before sought public office but quickly proved to be a formidable campaigner. In the August primary election, she defeated Senate President Pro Tempore Tim Ashe (D/P-Chittenden), Sen. Debbie Ingram (D-Chittenden) and activist Brenda Siegel.

Milne ran for governor in 2014, nearly toppling Democratic incumbent Peter Shumlin, and unsuccessfully challenged Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) in 2016.

Gray declared victory Tuesday night at the Great Northern restaurant and bar in Burlington.

“We’ve led in responding to the pandemic, but now it’s time to lead in responding to the climate crisis,” she said. “We can also lead in rooting out systemic racism wherever it exists, addressing poverty and social injustice — but we have to get it right. To quote the late justice Ruth Bader Ginsberg, we must fight in a way that brings other people to the table. We have to fight in a way that brings others to join us.”
Molly Gray on Tuesday night in Burlington - LUKE AWTRY
  • Luke Awtry
  • Molly Gray on Tuesday night in Burlington
Gray also alluded to her relative youth and her newfound place as a rising star of the Vermont Democratic Party.

“Our next generation is here, and we are ready to lead,” she said. “Together I know we can take Vermont forward. I also know we can be an example for the nation for how to come together, work together, put divisiveness aside and succeed together.”

The race for lieutenant governor grew nasty at times, with both candidates accusing the other of drawing support from shadowy outside organizations. Milne’s campaign was particularly aggressive, questioning whether Gray’s 15 months living in Switzerland in 2017 and 2018 made her constitutionally ineligible to serve as LG — and repeatedly highlighting her spotty voting record.

In her victory speech Tuesday, Gray criticized her opponent for pushing “misleading and nasty personal attacks” and called his negative television advertisements “an attempt to buy an election, destroy my reputation and diminish my integrity.”

Milne did not address the public Tuesday night but called Gray shortly after her speech to concede. “I am honored by the tens of thousands of Vermonters who supported my candidacy,” he said in a written statement. “I send my sincere congratulations to Molly Gray on her victory this evening. I wish her success moving forward.”
Scott Milne and Molly Gray debate during their campaign for lieutenant governor. - JEB WALLACE-BRODEUR
  • Jeb Wallace-Brodeur
  • Scott Milne and Molly Gray debate during their campaign for lieutenant governor.
U.S. Rep. Peter Welch (D-Vt.), the only member of Vermont’s congressional delegation up for reelection, easily won an eighth term. As of Wednesday morning, he was leading Republican Miriam Berry of Essex 65 to 26 percent.

Across Lake Champlain in New York’s 21st congressional district, U.S. Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-N.Y.) easily fended off second-time Democratic challenger Tedra Cobb, 64 to 36 percent.

Vermont saw little competition in most of its statewide races. Democratic state Treasurer Beth Pearce defeated her Republican challenger, former state legislator Carolyn Whitney Branagan, 54 to 31 percent, according to preliminary results. Democratic Secretary of State Jim Condos, Democratic Attorney General T.J. Donovan and Democratic/Progressive Auditor Doug Hoffer faced only token opposition from perennial candidates.

Speaker Johnson was not the only state legislative leader to lose her seat Wednesday night. Rep. Robin Chestnut-Tangerman (P-Middletown Springs), who heads the House Progressive Caucus, was felled by Republican Sally Achey, also of Middletown Springs. Achey picked up 1,417 votes, while Chestnut-Tangerman collected 1,385.

Those losses did not appear likely to dramatically shift the balance of power in the Vermont House, which has been firmly in the grasp of Democrats and Progressives in recent years.

In the Senate, Republicans were poised to pick up one seat. But Democrats and Progressive seemed certain to hold 23 of 30 seats.
Sen. John Rodgers with a hemp plant - FILE: ALICIA FREESE ©️ SEVEN DAYS
  • File: Alicia Freese ©️ Seven Days
  • Sen. John Rodgers with a hemp plant
The only imperiled incumbent in the state Senate was Sen. John Rodgers (D-Essex-Orleans), who failed to submit his nominating papers in time to appear on the ballot as a Democrat. He ran, instead, as an independent.

Preliminary results showed Rodgers trailing fellow incumbent Sen. Bobby Starr (D-Essex-Orleans), Republican Russ Ingalls, Republican Jonathan Morin and Democrat Ron Horton in the two-member district. Starr claimed 8,668 votes, Ingalls 7,734 — and Rodgers a distant 5,100.

The Senate will also include two new members from populous Chittenden County.

Kesha Ram, a Democrat from Burlington, and Thomas Chittenden, a Democrat from South Burlington, will join four incumbents in representing the six-member district: Sens. Ginny Lyons (D-Chittenden), Michael Sirotkin (D-Chittenden), Phil Baruth (D/P-Chittenden) and Chris Pearson (P/D-Chittenden). Seven others, including six Republicans, also ran in the district.

Ram, a former state representative who unsuccessfully ran for lieutenant governor in 2016, will be the first woman of color to serve in the Vermont Senate. She and Chittenden will replace Ashe and Ingram, both of whom gave up their seats to run in the Democratic primary for lieutenant governor.

The retirement of Sen. James McNeil (R-Rutland), triggered a 10-candidate contest for Rutland County’s three-seat Senate district. The two other incumbents, Sen. Brian Collamore (R-Rutland) and Sen. Cheryl Hooker (D-Rutland) both won reelection. Republican Joshua Terenzini won the third seat.

Other than Johnson’s and Chestnut-Tangerman’s losses, there appeared to be few upsets in Vermont House races. In one closely watched contest, Rep. Heidi Scheuermann (R-Stowe) easily defeated Democratic challenger Jo Sabel Courtney, 1,925 votes to 1,403.
Alyssa and Rob Black testifying before the Senate Judiciary Committee in February 2019 - FILE: TAYLOR DOBBS ©️ SEVEN DAYS
  • File: Taylor Dobbs ©️ Seven Days
  • Alyssa and Rob Black testifying before the Senate Judiciary Committee in February 2019
Democrat Alyssa Black of Essex Town, however, managed to unseat Rep. Bob Bancroft (R-Westford), an outspoken conservative. Black and her husband, Rob, became passionate advocates in the Statehouse for firearm waiting periods after their son, Andrew, died by suicide in 2018.

Rep. Cynthia Browning (D-Arlington), a thorn in the side to fellow Democrats, lost her reelection race. Browning drew the condemnation of many of her colleagues in March when she demanded that a quorum of the House attend an emergency session during the first wave of the coronavirus pandemic. Johnson soon stripped her of her committee assignment.

Browning subsequently renounced her party and ran as an independent in the two-member district. Fellow incumbent Rep. Kathleen James (D-Manchester) won reelection, while Democratic former legislator Seth Bongartz of Manchester bumped Browning out of contention.

Winooski voters, meanwhile, elected the state’s first openly transgender legislator, Democrat Taylor Small. She will join incumbent Rep. Hal Colston (D-Winooski) in representing the Onion City in the House. They defeated clean water advocate and former gubernatorial candidate James Ehlers, who also sought a seat in the Senate.

Winooski voters overwhelmingly approved a ballot item to allow noncitizen immigrants to vote in local elections, making it the second Vermont municipality to pass what’s known as “all-resident voting” in as many years.

The measure passed 2,479 to 999, according to unofficial results Tuesday night. The “yes” vote is to change the city’s charter, a decision that the state legislature and governor must now approve. Noncitizens would be able to vote in city and school elections; state and federal races would remain off-limits.

The vote is significant for Winooski, a city of 7,300 that boasts Vermont’s most diverse population and the state’s only majority-minority school district. Nearly 10 percent of residents there are not U.S. citizens.

Colin Flanders, Derek Brouwer, Kevin McCallum, Courtney Lamdin, Sasha Goldstein and Andrea Suozzo contributed reporting.

Related Stories

Speaking of...