Media Note: Newly Named Rutland Herald, T-A Publisher Cited for DUI | Off Message

Media Note: Newly Named Rutland Herald, T-A Publisher Cited for DUI


A mug shot of Catherine Nelson taken Saturday night in Rutland - RUTLAND POLICE DEPARTMENT
  • Rutland Police Department
  • A mug shot of Catherine Nelson taken Saturday night in Rutland
Updated Wednesday, December 30, 2015, at 5:56 p.m.

Two days before she was named publisher of the Rutland Herald and Barre-Montpelier Times Argus, the newspapers’ vice president and CEO was cited for driving under the influence of alcohol and leaving the scene of an accident.

According to the Rutland City Police Department, 64-year-old Catherine Nelson crashed her Nissan sport utility vehicle several times Saturday night in downtown Rutland and was found to be "over twice the legal limit to operate a vehicle."

Nelson's car hit a porch on Park Street, struck a guardrail on Porter Place and finally crashed into the Westminster Cracker Company building, "causing extensive front end damage to the vehicle," according to an incident report issued Tuesday evening by Patrol Sergeant Joseph Bartlett. The Rutland Police arrived on the scene shortly after 8 p.m., took Nelson into custody and issued a criminal citation for her to appear in court at a later date. Her car was towed away.

Nelson did not respond to Seven Days’ requests for comment Tuesday evening, but her lawyer, John J. Welch, later told the Herald, “Things will become clear as this evolves.” He cautioned observers “not [to] jump to any conclusions.”

It appears that Nelson’s boss, outgoing publisher R. John Mitchell, was aware of the incident when he announced to the papers’ employees Monday afternoon that she would succeed him, effective February 1. But according to two Herald staffers, neither Mitchell nor Nelson informed the newsroom that their new boss had been charged.

“I'm not aware of John telling the newsroom about the incident,” Herald news editor Alan Keays told Seven Days Wednesday afternoon. “I certainly believe it would have been more appropriate for the newsroom to have learned about the incident sooner.”

Instead, broke the story Tuesday afternoon. Roughly an hour later, the Herald posted a three-sentence brief about the incident on its website. The Herald and T-A published a more complete account in Wednesday’s papers.

Keays said he learned about the incident “from an off-the-record tip” he received Tuesday afternoon. He assigned crime and justice reporter Kathleen Phalen-Tomaselli to cover it. Both said they did their best to treat the situation as if it did not involve their boss and said management did not interfere.

“As a reporter, I was told to cover this story as I always would cover this type of incident,” Phalen-Tomaselli said. “The senior managers I interviewed told me to do my job as I always do. There were no instructions or guidance given.”

Mitchell declined to grant Seven Days an interview Tuesday or Wednesday, but he spoke with Phalen-Tomaselli for her story. His account appeared somewhat contradictory.

“Mitchell said he was aware Nelson was cited for drunken driving prior to announcing her promotion Monday afternoon,” Phalen-Tomaselli wrote. Later, though, she quoted Mitchell as saying, “What I know, I read on our website.”

In response to Seven Days’ questions, Mitchell wrote in an email Wednesday that he was “sticking by what was written in Kathleen's story this morning, which was based on what I knew each time I was asked during the day and evening by her.” He did not say why he and Nelson evidently kept the information from their own reporters. He also declined to say whether the incident influenced in any way the timing of Monday’s management announcement.

The outgoing publisher, however, appears to be standing by his successor, who has worked for the papers since 2006.

“This has no bearing on her qualifications to be publisher,” Mitchell told the Herald. “Based on a limited amount of information, there is no reason to doubt her or to not be fully supportive of her.”

Related Stories

Speaking of...


Comments (2)

Showing 1-2 of 2


Comments are closed.

From 2014-2020, Seven Days allowed readers to comment on all stories posted on our website. While we've appreciated the suggestions and insights, right now Seven Days is prioritizing our core mission — producing high-quality, responsible local journalism — over moderating online debates between readers.

To criticize, correct or praise our reporting, please send us a letter to the editor or send us a tip. We’ll check it out and report the results.

Online comments may return when we have better tech tools for managing them. Thanks for reading.